Friday, 12 October 2018

Epic 4K: Skitarii vs Tau

After last game where Andrew used the Skitarri list we swapped over and I gave it a try. I had been rather vocal on Tactical Command forums recommending that the Quake Cannon Ordinatus should cost more points and thus we thought we would try them at the suggested 600 rather than 500 points in this game. Similarly I used the Golgotha which is another war engine macro artillery formation (though more limited in that it will have probably run out of ammo by turn 4), at 550 rather than 500 points.

For this game I used a mix of Imperial and Chaos war engine models and infantry, though I did actually have one of the Ordinatus style models from Vanguard for the Majoris!

Incompertus, 4000 POINTS 
Gryphonne IV Skitarii Legion (NetEA 2.1 (Approved Candidate version)) 
================================================== 

ORDINATUS MAJORUS [550] 
1 Ordinatus Majorus, Ordinatus Golgotha (Hellfire Missiles)

ORDINATUS MINORUS [600] 
2 Ordinatus Minorus, Minorus with Carapace Landing Pad, 2 Minorus with Quake Cannon

SAGITARII DEMI-CENTURY [275] 
5 Sagitarii units, 5 Rapiers

SAGITARII DEMI-CENTURY [275] 
5 Sagitarii units, 5 Rapiers

SKITARII DEMI-CENTURY [425] 
2 Secutor units, 8 Hypaspist units, Magos Character, Minorus with Support Missile

SKITARII DEMI-CENTURY [225] 
2 Secutor units, 8 Hypaspist units

SKITARII DEMI-CENTURY [225] 
2 Secutor units, 8 Hypaspist units

ORDINATUS MINORUS [425] 
2 Ordinatus Minorus, 3 Minorus with Gatling Blaster

ORDINATUS MINORUS [425] 
2 Ordinatus Minorus, 3 Minorus with Gatling Blaster

ORDINATUS MINORUS [575] 
2 Ordinatus Minorus, 3 Minorus with Plasma Destructor  


Andrew used his Viorla Tau with a heavy number of tanks.

4000 points, Third Phase Tau v6.8

375FW Cadre, 2 Pathfinders, 8 Fire Warriors, Ethereal, Devilfish
325FW Cadre, 8 Fire Warriors, Skyray
325FW Cadre, 6 Fire Warriors, 3 Devilfish, Skyray
225FW Cadre, 6 Fire Warriors, 3 Devilfish
2004 Fusion Hammerheads
3004 Fusion Hammerheads, Skyray
2254 Railhead Hammerheads
2254 Railhead Hammerheads
2254 Railhead Hammerheads
175Kroot Kindred, Shaper, 9 Warriors
175Kroot Kindred, Shaper, 9 Warriors
200Pathfinder Group, 4 Pathfinders, 2 Devilfish
1754 Tetra, 2 Piranha
1754 Tetra, 2 Piranha
1752 Tetra, 4 Piranha
200Protector Class Cruiser
1502 Barracuda
1502 Barracuda



Turn 1

Here's the setup. I am clustered near the ruins in the centre of the table though with some Minoris on the flanks. The Tau are spread out to avoid the artillery barrages, and with plenty of garrisons forward of the line.


I win strategy roll and open up with the one shot Minoris Barrage wrecking one of the Tau formations and putting BM on two others.

The Tau concentrate fire against my Plasma Destructor Ordinatus with co-ordinated fire, so that I end up just marshalling them to remove blast markers and restore shields. Thus they cancel out the firepower that had been just been thrown at them, but the Ordinatus are not able to do use their own guns in return. Given they are slow firing and can only fire every second turn I decide this is not a great disaster though.

My Hypaspists engage in a firefight and wipe out a suppressed Kroot Formation in the centre of the table, and take one of the buildings.

The Tau then concentrate fire on my left most Ordinatus formation stripping shields and breaking them, and the Tau Spacecraft arrives and misses with one shot, but destroys an Ordinatus with the other.

More fire is exchanged, with the Tau Fusion Hammerheads managing to break my lead Hypaspist formation and force it to retreat, and several more Tau formations being mauled. The Majoris wrecks a Hammerhead formation destroying two tanks.


End of turn 1 losses.

Note all the dead Secutors who had no luck with saves this game against Tau Fusion Hammerheads and Snipers!

Turn 2

Tau win Strategy Roll, and launch a co-ordinated fire mission with Recon and two Hammerhead formations. This breaks my lead Minoris formation and destroys one of it' number, and they fall back shields down.


The Majoris fires again and wrecks another Hammerhead Railgun formation before it can activate, destroying two tanks. Hammerheads are a priority target given their threat to Ordinatus units.

More fire is exchanged and Kroot sweep forward in a firefight breaking a Sagitarri formation, losing two of their own in the exchange.

End of turn 2 before rallies.

Below the Plasma Destructors have advanced and fire two of their number wiping out a Recon formation, their massive guns being an expensive and too heavy option for the matchup in this game!

The centre showing the battle for the objectives and buildings here.

Turn 3

Both sides infantry continue to take heavy losses in the built up area as buildings are contested, and locations change hands.

The Plasma Destructors advance wrecking more Tau tanks though only one can fire this turn. Ordinatus artillery continues to take a heavy toll with each barrage rendering a Tau formation combat ineffective.

A look at the situation in the centre. My Supreme Commanders formation has advanced to contest the central building but a Tau Sniper takes out my Magos so no more rerolls!

View from my baseline.

Turn 4

Tau have been throwing forward broken formations to slow the Skitarri advance and prevent me winning on objectives. Even the Tau Command formation takes on this role, and their Supreme Commander is also killed along with his entire formation.  The Minoris Quake Cannon formation manages to get lucky and shoot down three Barracuda with its AA just to add insult to this loss.


The Majoris is out of barrage ammo, so drives forward to use its hull weapons, which still helps out against broken Tau formations. 

Turn ends and I have the 'Break Their Spirit' victory condition but nothing else, and the Tau have "Take and Hold" but no other victory condition.  Game fails to go to a turn 5 and so we go to Victory Points.

Skitarri have destroyed 2887.5 points of Tau.

Tau have only destroyed 1362.5 of Skitarri so a win to Skitarri.

Conclusion

A protracted battle of attrition, but the Skitarri forces managed to out-attrition the more lightly armoured Tau in the end. One point in the Tau favour in this battle was that the Ordinatii firepower (e.g. Plasma Destructors) was often overkill and thus inefficient against the 'pop-corn' style list used here with 18 Tau formations vs 10 Skitarri. The artillery Ordinatii were reliably destructive and didn't fail an activation in the game which added to that effectiveness. They were also so well protected by shields and being at the back of the table that the Tau prioritised targeting the more easily reachable Ordinatii which could be markerlighted/crossfired. This was probably a wise move as the firepower from these was also more immediately destructive in power, though also much more vulnerable and challenging to employ as effectively. 

I think we felt the increased points were justified for the artillery Ordinatii, and other formations probably felt about right from this game, though we are planning to test the list again. One thing we also thought was that the ratios and lack of upgrade options in a Skitarii list mean you are rather set in what you can take, and coming up with an exact 4000 points list or something close to that is rather challenging (when using lots of Ordinatii at least). You can take Hydras as an upgrade for 50 points of course, that is a waste when you have integral AA on the Ordinatii. More to ponder...

Wednesday, 3 October 2018

Epic 4K: Fir Iolarion vs Skitarri

Another game using Fir Iolarion, this time with the new 4.2.6 list released the same day. 

FIR IOLARION ELDAR TITAN CLAN (4.2.6) 4000 POINTS

WARLOCK TITAN [900]
1 Warlock Titan, Power Fist, Psychic Lance, Bonesinger

PHANTOM TITAN [750]
1 Phantom Titan, 2 Titan Pulsar

REVENANT TITAN TWINS [700]
2 Revenant Titans, 2 Revenant Pulse Laser Pair, Spiritstones

WRAITHKNIGHT TROUPE [350]
Three Wraithknights, 3 2 x Heavy Wraithcannon

WRAITHKNIGHT TROUPE [350]
Three Wraithknights, 3 Suncannon

WRAITHKNIGHT TROUPE [350]
Three Wraithknights, 3 Ghosglaive and Spiritshield.

WRAITHLORDS [250]
4 Wraithlords

REVENANT TITAN SINGLE [350]
1 Revenant Titan, Revenant Pulse Laser Pair


Andrew used the 2.1 Skitarii list:

19th Armoured Regiment, Lunar Defence Force, 
today, count as Adeptus Mechanicus, Skitarii, v.2.1

2 Secutors, Magos, 8 Hypaspists, Ordinatus Minorus (Barrage, 10BP, Disrupt, Single Shot) [425]
2 Secutors, 8 Hypaspists, Ordinatus Minorus (Barrage, 10BP, Disrupt, Single Shot) [375]
2 Secutors, 8 Hypaspists [225]
2 Secutors, 8 Hypaspists [225]
5 Sagitarii, 5 Rapiers [275]

3 Ordinatus Minorus (1 Carapace Landing Pad, 2 Quake Cannons, 3BP, MW) [500]
3 Ordinatus Minorus (2 Gattling Blasters, Plasma Destructor) [475]
3 Ordinatus Minorus (2 Gattling Blasters, Plasma Destructor) [475]
3 Ordinatus Minorus (Gattling Blasters, 6 x AP4+/AT4+) [425]
2 Ordinatus Minorus (Plasma Destructors, 5 x MW2+, Slow Fire) [400]

2 Avenger Strike Fighters [200]


Turn 1

Setup as below. I'm spread out to try and minimise barrage effectiveness.

Skitarri positions.


I win Strategy Roll, but let the Skitarri activate first. They fire off their Ordinatus one shot 10BP (!) barrages and break both my Phantom and Warlock, though do not damage them. The break move is forwards to ruins for both these Titans.

The Eldar move forward under a barrage of fire, taking many blastmarkers and one of the Revenants also loses its holofield. Two Knights with Wriathcannon are also destroyed. In return the garrisoning Sagitarri and Rapiers unit takes heavy casualties and fall back.  


Rallies will be crucial for the Eldar!

And fortunately the rolls are good!

Turn 2

Winning Strategy Roll again, the Warlock assaults a Hypaspist unit in a firefight intending to win and consolidate towards the Ordinatus ready for a followup assault. This goes disastrously though, partly due to not being able to get enough of the enemy in range (only three stands), and also with the Warlock taking a point of damage, losing its Holofield and loses the firefight!  

The Warlock falls back, and Revenant pair and Phantom wreck a three strong Ordinatus formation in a third retain.

After some long range macro barrages from Ordinatus, the Eldar try another firefight with Knights against the weakened Hypaspists, but this is another loss and the Knights lose one of their number, take damage on another, and retreat. 

Things look grim for the Eldar at the end of turn 2!

Turn 3

The Eldar rally again, but the Skitarri win Strategy Roll and consolidate their position into an unassailable lead by destroying the weakened Warlock Titan and having too many activations remaining. I concede!

Conclusion

A tough matchup with all the incoming blast marker suppression first turn. I needed to not panic and time targets better from turn two onwards. However the thought of all the slow firing but deadly Ordinatus weapons (plasma destructors) being recharged for turn three encouraged urgency and calculated but risky assaults turn two. These didn't pay off though even if they had it still would have been a very tough fight! Likely I would have been better to hang back, concentrate more on maneuver and shooting despite the danger. Skitarri is still an list in development so who stats may change for future games also.